Which is Better: An Apartment or Independent House?

Owning a home is a financial goal that transcends religion and nationality. Once the requisite financial planning is done and the necessary savings accumulated, the next question is whether to buy an apartment or an independent house. Usually, space crunch and high rates in metros compel most homebuyers to look at apartments as their preferred choice. These come slightly cheaper than independent property which could be in the form of a villa or an assortment of floors built on a plot. However, there are many factors to consider like location, accessibility, rent, appreciation, security, purpose of purchase, stage of life, etc., before one makes this once-in-a-lifetime investment. A bunch of independent houses clubbed together known as colonies are a common sight in the country but economic factors and urban lifestyle have dealt a death knell for the culture of independent houses especially in metropolitan cities. The rise in nuclear families, upgrade in compact & chic lifestyle, increase in land cost, and inter-state migration of the population for jobs led to the practical flourishing of apartment culture in the big cities. Vertical growth has now extended to shopping malls multi-storeyed office space and technology parks as well.


Apartments are the most popular type of property across cities in India because of reasons like contemporary looks, modern-day amenities, in-house maintenance services, and better security. Apartments are a good choice for self-use, renting as well as for investment purposes. Apartments are at par with independent houses in all respects and as far as customisation is concerned, it can be done at a small scale without altering the basic set-up of the apartment.


Independent House

Independent houses or villas are preferred by those who want the privacy of an independent unit but also want to avoid the hassle of constructing a home. Some developers even offer premium units in gated communities with individual or shared amenities. The owner has privacy and control over the design and architecture of the house along with cost-effective use of materials and quality. One can build multiple floors and self-occupy one floor and rent out the rest which would be a good source of income but will be taxable. Maintenance charges are a self-bearing cost for a lifetime and the safety and security of the house has to be taken by self only. The land has great appreciation and resale value if one has the patience to keep it for the long term. It is also an heirloom which will be beneficial for the future generations.


Apartment vs Independent House:

1. The cost of buying an independent house is much higher than that of buying an apartment hence in the case of a home loan the requirement will increase correspondingly. It would include the price of the plot, the stamp duty to be paid to the Govt., the clearances required from various authorities, the cost for an electricity connection, raw materials, labor costs depending on the city, and the architect fees in case of renovations. In the case of an apartment, the builder takes care of the technical formalities and the buyer just has to pay the requisite amount for the apartment and move in whenever one desires.


2. While an apartment property comes with added values, such as security, enough parking space, power back-up, water systems, and fire safety mechanisms in place, an independent property needs extra effort to set up of these services. This would also include an extra cost of 2-3% of the total property value on these amenities around an independent villa property. This would include setting up of a small power back-up in the form of an inverter or a generator set and your water mechanism.


3. Banks sanction loans for independent properties only after strict scrutiny of borrowers which is time-consuming and may lead to losing out on the desired property. Loans for apartments are readily available as builders have tie-ups with various banks to make it a more hassle-free process.


4. Owning a property needs financial resources and constant efforts for maintenance, cleanliness, and construction & repair whereas in a society with apartments, they have a dedicated in-house maintenance team that takes care of everything and is available round the clock at a reasonable expense due to the pooled resources.


5. When it comes to independent houses or villas, capital appreciation is not as high as an apartment. This is largely due to the high initial capital involved and the limited demand as compared to apartments. For the same reason, it is difficult to sell an independent house. Apartments on the other hand are always in demand and easy to sell or rent out.


6. If one is an inexperienced new buyer, one could fall prey to title fraud and scams when purchasing an independent house. In the case of apartments, buyers can check the reputation and past record of the builder of delivering projects and their quality and can also fact-check with the existing residents. This helps in investing the hard-earned money in a trustworthy project.


7. Living in an apartment complex encourages communal harmony and societal living as no discrimination is made based on caste or creed. Society members from all walks of life are welcomed which is lacking in independent house living. 



An independent house will be best suited for someone who has a big family and is particular about the aesthetics of their home, the neighborhood, and its privacy, and also has the financial strength to complement such a lifestyle. Someone who doesn’t want to be bothered by the technical hassles of buying a plot and constructing a house can go for an already-built independent house.


For buyers like a modern nuclear family on a budget or seniors looking to spend their retirement in peace; Retirement Homes are the best option. This financial logic has resulted in tier II cities also opting for apartments. The builders have sensed the demand and are catering to it for every budget and providing all sorts of amenities and facilities to attract such buyers.

In the real estate market, there are mostly two kinds of prospective buyers. Some want to buy a house for personal use while others want to make the most of an investment opportunity. For the former category, the primary focus should be on the amenities, proximity to business hubs, comfort, and aesthetic beauty of the home. Investors need to look at the current trend as to what property rents out the most these days, what kind of returns can be expected, what the resale value is, etc. While it is easier to find tenants for apartments due to huge demand, rent yield is higher for independent houses depending on factors like size of room, and locality among other things. 

Don't forget to share this valuable article with others


About The Author

Ashiana, Ashiana Housing build homes. Homes surrounded by vast green spaces and fresh breeze. Homes cocooned in secured gated complexes. Homes where futures are forged and there are opportunities to grow. And Homes in environments brimming with healthy activity, trust and respect. At heart, we build communities with care.

Other posts by


Subscribe Now to our blog. Stay up to date with the latest real estate market, investment option, updates on senior living & kid centric world & Just enter your email address to subscribe

Join 1000+ of fellow readers. Get expert real estate knowledge straight to your inbox absolutely free. Just enter your email address below.

Get our blogs straight in your inbox,
know real estate better:
Write a Review
yash kumararjun suravaram

yash kumar and 1 others have reviewed this place


yash kumar

yash kumar

4 years  ago

Any update on the Union Budget 2020?



Dear Yash, Please read our Union Budget Blog - https://www.ashianahousing.com/real-estate-blog/union-budget-2019-2020 Regards, Team Ashiana

arjun suravaram

arjun suravaram

4 years  ago

Hey, I noticed your Article. I just loved it. Thank you for your immense care in planning and choosing the right resources and execution, be it the drawings, construction material and Vaastu to a clear title. Here is the right place that is waiting for you I like it and share it. Cheers.



Dear Arjun, Thank you for liking and sharing our blog :D Regards, Team Ashiana


wait your request is under process

Site Visit

wait your request is under process